A
Crash Course in Music Licensing
by
Donald R. Simon, Esq.
Originally published in Screen
Magazine, February 23, 2004, at 23.
One
of the most misunderstood areas of copyright law applicable to advertising is
music licensing. Music clearance and licensing can be tedious, and if not
done properly, can cause great problems for a commercial producer or ad
agency. This article addresses some of the major issues involved in music
licensing and walks through the licensing process with the band Missile, a
Chicago trio.
If
music is being licensed from a third party publisher, music house, or record
label, or as in this example, from a band, two separate copyrights must be
licensed: (1) the musical composition (usually the lyrics), often owned by a
music publisher; and (2) the specific recording of that composition, usually
owned by the artists record company (here its Pop-e Records).
Licensing of these two copyrights is generally called synchronization (or
"sync") rights and master recording rights, respectively.
It
is possible to license sync rights from the music publisher
without needing master rights from the record company if the music
is created specifically for the production, such as being sung by
a new performer or recorded by an agency composer. If a
master recording is used, however, a sync license must also be
obtained unless the recording is of a composition in the public
domain. Because any one song may have several different
recorded versions, the owner of the sync right will remain
constant while the owner of the master will vary depending on
which recorded version used. Of course if the music was an
original composition created in-house, there is no need to acquire
a sync or master license (which can have implications under the
"works-made-for-hire" doctrine).
But
its free advertisement, right?
One of the exclusive rights afforded a copyright holder under the
copyright laws is the right to reproduce and authorize a
reproduction of a copyrighted work in television programs, motion
pictures, and/or commercials. In other words, Missile, or
any copyright owner for that matter, has a right to control
so-called "free advertisement."
Can
I use copyrighted music in an ad for a school or church without
first obtaining a license? No. All the same
copyright and licensing rules apply regardless of the status of
your client. It makes no difference whether your client is a
non-profit, educational, or charitable organization, if Missiles
or any other copyrighted music is going to be used in an ad, it
must be licensed for that purpose. The "fair use"
doctrine does not apply.
What
about the "8-bar rule?"
Many commercial producers are under the mistaken impression that a
small portion of a copyrighted work may be used without obtaining
a license. One often hears, "You can use X number of
bars for free." This is totally false. Any part
of copyrighted music reproduced in a production must be
licensed. The "fair use" doctrine does not apply.
OK,
so how is music licensed?
Say, youd like to license Missiles "Set In Motion"
from their new CD "Welcome to the End of My Rope."
The first step is identifying the copyright owners of the
material. In this case its the bands vocalist and guitarist,
Don Weaver. However, copyright ownership may be split among
several parties, so it is essential to make sure that you locate
all parties that have an interest in a particular song. With
master recordings, generally there will be one record company to
deal with, although sometimes the rights may be split by
territory, especially for foreign artists. For example, one
company may have rights for the United States while another may
have rights for the balance of the World. In our example,
Pop-e Records controls all master recordings by Missile throughout
the World.
Remember
that many different songs may have the same title and that there
may be several different versions of the same song by different
artists on separate record labels. If the recording to be
licensed comes from a compilation or soundtrack album, there is a
strong possibility that the record company that released the album
does not control the recording, but licensed the track from the
artists original record company. Be sure that you are
researching and licensing the right song and version.
Be
sure to include in the license agreement what is necessary to
accomplish the intended use of the advertising, i.e., the desired
media (television, radio, industrial use, Internet, etc.),
territory, and duration, as well as options for extending the
length or scope of the licenses. Exceeding the scope or
duration of a music license is copyright infringement. Damages for
copyright infringement can be quite high. The copyright
owner may receive statutory damages ranging from $750 to $30,000
for each infringement, or actual damages and any profits
attributable to the infringement. In addition, punitive
damages may be awarded for particularly egregious situations.
Given
their frequent complexity, synchronization licenses for musical
compositions and master recording licenses for musical recordings
should always be reviewed by legal counsel in order to best ensure
that all desired rights have been effectively secured. You
can reach Missile c/o Pop-e Records, 116 W. Illinois 2 West,
Chicago, IL 60610, or at missile@pop-e.com.